Tracy and I had a really nice chat the other week with Emily of FemRadio at Ryerson University.
“This week on FemRadio, Emily chats with Samantha Brennan and Tracy Isaacs — two feminist philosophers and fitness fanatics who co-founded the blog “Fitness is a Feminist Issue.” We discuss the meaning of body positivity, fitness myths that need to end, and the complexities of pursuing fitness as a feminist.”
My book group read Shrill: Notes from a Loud Woman this month and I kept highlighting passages on my Kindle to use later on the blog. I haven’t finished it yet. I’m about halfway through. I’m that kind of book group member. (I did bring not one, but two, delicious salads.) But that hasn’t stopped me from telling people to read it. It’s so good. I love her voice and her story.
For now here are some great Lindy West quotes from Shrill.
And you can read her this week in the New York Times too.
“Don’t tell thin women to eat a cheeseburger. Don’t tell fat women to put down the fork. Don’t tell underweight men to bulk up. Don’t tell women with facial hair to wax, don’t tell uncircumcised men they’re gross, don’t tell muscular women to go easy on the dead-lift, don’t tell dark-skinned women to bleach their vagina, don’t tell black women to relax their hair, don’t tell flat-chested women to get breast implants, don’t tell “apple-shaped” women what’s “flattering,” don’t tell mothers to hide their stretch marks, and don’t tell people whose toes you don’t approve of not to wear flip-flops. And so on, etc, etc, in every iteration until the mountains crumble to the sea. Basically, just go ahead and CEASE telling other human beings what they “should” and “shouldn’t” do with their bodies unless a) you are their doctor, or b) SOMEBODY GODDAMN ASKED YOU.”
“Please don’t forget: I am my body. When my body gets smaller, it is still me. When my body gets bigger, it is still me. There is not a thin woman inside me, awaiting excavation. I am one piece.”
“Maybe you are thin. You hiked that trail and you are fit and beautiful and wanted and I am so proud of you, I am so in awe of your wiry brightness; and I’m miles behind you, my breathing ragged. But you didn’t carry this up the mountain, You only carried yourself. How hard would you breathe if you had to carry me? You couldn’t. But I can.”
“Denying people access to value is an incredibly insidious form of emotional violence, one that our culture wields aggressively and liberally to keep marginalized groups small and quiet.”
“As a woman, my body is scrutinized, policed, and treated as a public commodity. As a fat woman, my body is also lampooned, openly reviled, and associated with moral and intellectual failure. My body limits my job prospects, access to medical care and fair trials, and – the one thing Hollywood movies and Internet trolls most agree on – my ability to be loved. So the subtext, when a thin person asks a fat person, ‘Where do you get your confidence?’ is, ‘You must be some sort of alien because if I looked like you, I would definitely throw myself into the sea.”
“I reject the notion that thinness is the goal, that thin = better—that I am an unfinished thing and that my life can really start when I lose weight. That then I will be a real person and have finally succeeded as a woman. I am not going to waste another second of my life thinking about this. I don’t want to have another fucking conversation with another fucking woman about what she’s eating or not eating or regrets eating or pretends to not regret eating to mask the regret. OOPS I JUST YAWNED TO DEATH.”
Before the race, it’s Susan, Sam and Sarah sporting ball caps and a scarf. Ready to run!
Sarah: I went into this year’s duathlon having hardly trained for the run at all, thanks to the springtime trifecta of bad weather, long hours at the office, and laziness.No personal bests were in store for me, so I went for a nice jog and a bike ride on the shores of Lake Huron, and learned some things along the way.
1) There is some weirdness in the final results. I assume this is of my own making – I started one age group late (with the 45+ crowd) so I could pace Sam for the beginning of her run, but ended up with a super slow result on the first 3km (26:30?!), and a guntime almost 3 minutes slower than Sam’s despite starting at the same time and beating her to the finish. I can only guess they used the “gun” for the start of my age group and added the difference between it and when I actually started. My inner competitor is frustrated that the result doesn’t reflect all the people I’d doggedly passed on the 2nd run, but if I really was just going for a leisurely run and cycle along the lake, I oughtn’t really care. Lesson learned, start with your age group!
2) Speaking of competition, I’m normally pretty anxious before any kind of race / performance test. Serious, focused, short fuse, can’t eat, etc. Kincardine is unique for me – staying in a tiny tourist cottage with Sam and Susan T, hanging out at the start with Susan F and Tara, meant eating breakfast and smiling while I stretched and warmed up. Lesson learned, the feeling of a community event built around supporting individual efforts is unique and to be treasured.
3) Sam passed me on the bike (no surprise there!) so I had a chance to play with my pacing as I tried to catch her. I had always supposed that I would be faster overall running 2-3 minute intervals with a 1-minute fast walk between – but I definitely gained more ground on Sam running at a steady (tempo run) pace. Lesson learned, worth it to just keep running if I can.
4) I’ve been learning that eating sooner and more frequently on long bike rides really helps to prevent the lulls in energy I start to encounter after the 1-hour mark, so I thought I’d try some quick nutrition (one of those performance energy gel things) during the transition from the first run to the bike. Lesson learned, there is no amount of water I can guzzle that will keep that gel from making me nauseated during the first part of the ride.
5) I also have trouble with my calves and feet cramping up – albeit on long ride more than running – and was curious to see if I would encounter them in the duathlon. I certainly did – at the beginning of the second run. Fortunately I had my usual cure, Endurance Tap (a Canadian-made salted maple syrup “gel”), in my pocket. I was able to walk off the cramps in a couple hundred metres, with (yay!) no nausea in sight. I think I’ll stick to these for future races.
6) For those nerds interested in numbers that remember Sam’s Sunday post about heart rate, here is my heart rate for the bike portion of the course – truncated a little because I didn’t actually start my Garmin until I was halfway up the hill that starts the course.
Average heart rate : 165
Max heart rate : 175
You can see that Sam and I both have maximum heart rates very close to the standard calculation of 220 minus our respective ages. I’m ten years younger and run 10 BPM higher. Our average heart rates were at 92-94% of maximum – even when I felt like I was “taking it easy” in the middle portion of the course to not completely wear myself out pedalling into the wind, I was still up over 90%. And otherwise you can see the effect of the hills on both our hearts.
Sarah is a duathlete that doesn’t actually like running. She is riding her bike from Toronto to Port Hope on the Friends for Life Bike Rally’s 1-Day ride with a few fellow Fit Is A Feminist Issue bloggers. You can sponsor her here.
Sam: For me Kincardine is one of those events that I seem to enjoy at any speed. I’ve been struggling with sore arthritic knees that get in the way of training for the run. Instead, I’m the Queen of Knee Physio. My goal has been to run slowly and pain free. And I did it. Sarah has been encouraging me to find a sustainable slow running pace and it seems to have worked. Her coaching efforts paid off at Kincardine and at the Pride Run a few weeks before that. As usual I had a blast on the bike even securing a couple of personal bests on the Strava segments on the course. Thanks tailwinds! But best of all this was doing the race with friends. Great to see Susan F, Tara, and Carolyn there. Susan T, Sarah, and I shared a funky little cottage nearby, so close we got to shower and clean up between the race and awards and prizes. Will I do it again? Sure. And next year, this Queen of Knee Physio even hopes to be able to train for it. Wish me luck.
All cleaned up after the race! It’s Susan, Sarah, and Sam
You can read more race reports here and here and here.
If you want to do it with us next year, we’d love to have you along! You need to get up early on New year’s Day though. The registration sells out in the first hour or so.
This is the second in a new series where we answer readers’ questions.
Dear FFI, could you recommend a good beginners guide to weight training at home? A book or a web resource. I’d like to start gently and can’t go to the gym. Thanks in advance!
Sam says, “I like Stumptuous. Here’s her advice on setting up a home gym. And not quite a how-to book and with apologies for the title, I also like The New Rules of Lifting for Women: Lift Like a Man, Look Like a Goddess (2008). Also have a look at NerdFitnessfor their Strength Training 101.
Tracy likes Nia Shanks. She says, “I would recommend Nia Shanks, Lift Like a Girl. The website is pretty good. The Beautiful Badass workouts have modifications and variations for home training. She’s not perfect in staying away from weight loss/diet talk, but she’s better than most. And if you purchase the PDF of Beautiful Badass you gain access to youtube videos that aren’t otherwise searchable.”
What do you think? What do you recommend? Suggest away in the comments.
So if you have questions send them our way, using the “contact us” form on the left hand side of the blog. I’ll forward them to the appropriate blogger. We’re not experts by any means but we do have a wealth of real world experience with many, many physical activities.
Group picture at Kincardine Triathlon and Duathlon. The front row (left to right) is Susan F, Carolyn, and Tara. The back row (left to right) is Susan T, Sam, and Sarah.
Tara: For the last three years, I have done the duathlon (run 3k, bike 12k, run 3k). Last year, even though I didn’t appreciate it at the time, I think I was the fittest I’ve ever been. I was running regularly, even training some would say, I was biking a fair bit and had other sports that I played as well. I look back and marvel at my fitness level last year and am disappointed that I didn’t appreciate it more at the time. So this year, I’m working on being more thoughtful and appreciative of me and what’s going on around me. I’m still fit…just less so than last year and that’s okay! I’m able to move without pain, I’m fast, I can go out and run 5k with minimal training and I play soccer on three teams. I’m healthy and that’s nothing to take for granted! My race went well. It was a beautiful sunny day, I hung out with family, race friends, and met new people. Goal achieved for me. I raced, completed it well and had a great time! I’ve already marked my calendar for next year’s race and if it doesn’t sell out before I sign up, then I hope to do it again next year. Signing up for this race is a bit like buying concert tickets, it sells out within a very short time (hours and sometimes less) and I think that says a lot about this race…people love it and I do too.
Tara has two busy boys, a husband and a new puppy. She also coaches U10 boys soccer, plays soccer with a lot of fun people, runs, bikes and works full-time.
Carolyn: This year was my first time doing the Kincardine triathlon or any triathlon for that matter. I did try registering for it in a previous year but couldn’t get my act together in time on New Year’s Day to get in before all of the spots were gone. I’m glad I was successful this year, because the race was great! Since I have two youngish children, I didn’t have much time to train, although the running around that comes with having kids I think allowed me to be fit enough to feel moderately comfortable during the race. I found the swim mercifully short and not too difficult; however, I’ve spent every summer of my life swimming in Lake Huron and so had no fear of the water or the waves. The worst part for me, hands down, was the run, despite the fact that running is the only activity of the three that I had competed in in the past. Transitioning from bike to run was hard, and I’ll definitely practice that before doing the race again. I’ve already committed to doing it again with my friend Jane, and hope to convince other friends to join us. What a wonderful way to begin the summer!
Carolyn McLeod is Professor of Philosophy and Women’s Studies and Feminist Research at Western University. Her extended family of McLeods hail from Southampton Ontario, where she spent her summers as a child and learned to swim in Lake Huron.
Susan T: This was my first year doing this event and also my first duathlon. I have been very focused on running this year and was only out on my bike twice before the race so I was trying to hold lightly the outcome. I had also just had a super disappointing race two weeks prior were I went for a personal best and ended up burning out and feeling awful. I drove up to Kincardine after driving back from camping in Cornwall and I was really just looking at it as a social event. I kept whispering to myself, “This is not a competition, this is not a competition, this is not a competition. . . .Bahahaha who are you kidding?” It turns out it was a redemptive experience. Yay. I felt great and the temperature was perfect. I flew through the first 3k and then got on my bike. MY CLIPS DIDN’T WORK. Always safety check these things people. I managed to fly along the bike course anyway and didn’t fall off because of unclipped feet. The second run was a bit leaden feeling but I was still going at a good pace so I was happy. I finished strong. I will definitely try to do this event again. The best part is doing it with friends 🙂
Susan blogs regularly at Fit is a Feminist Issue. You can read all of her posts here.
You can also read Julie’s race report here and Susan F’s race report here.
And you’re still waiting for race reports from Sam and Sarah!
Last week I had a setback one day — this happens in our line of work. We get literal “rejections” all the time. This was a big one that stung and made me feel professionally incompetent for a few hours.
Anita asked me what I was going to do to pamper myself later that day. I said I might go for a night run. Now, to some this may not seem like pampering. But it has been hot and I hadn’t managed to get out. To top it all off, I’d been at the dentist earlier that day (yeah: talk about a banner day! A rejection and two fillings!) and the freezing just hung on way beyond what seemed reasonable.
By the time my mouth un-numbed just after 9, and I was still in a bit of a funk, I threw on my running gear and was about to grab my Garmin Forerunner when a little voice inside said, “Leave it.” Then I reached for my Timex Ironman watch, thinking at least I could time myself if not track pace and mileage. But the little voice spoke again: “Leave that too.”
Out I went, just after dusk, with no gadgets (well, okay, I had my Pulse, but that’s because of the step challenge and I’m not about to forgo tracking steps that I’m going to get anyway).
Upshot: it was wonderful. I felt free and at peace. The night air was a perfect temperature and even after my planned route I didn’t want to come in. I ended up running around the block a few more times.
How about you? Do you ever go night running? Do you ever run without gadgets? Have you ever done both at the same time??
Reflections on my first duathlon ever are mixed and embedded with my own approach to life of not necessarily reading the directions!
I was not that committed to the race but I was up and it was paid for and what else was I doing on a Saturday morning, right? So off we went for the 2 hour drive from home to arrive at the registration tents at 8:20 am. (Just as a note the cut off for registration was 8:30 so in my world we were there with plenty of time.)
The women staffing the tent seemed distracted and handed me my number and sent my tag to be ripped for a prize draw. I was quickly passed a bag and a shirt and almost dropped it all on the ground. These facts will be important later. After this I went and took my bike to the place marked ‘Bikes In.’
I then went to the washroom where I realized there was some organization to the bikes and I was in the wrong place but no worries. I moved my bike to the right place and tried to figure out where to go. Then I realized something was missing … chip yes the chip! As well everyone else was marked up with numbers and I was not and it was now 8:45 – 15 minutes to race time.
No worries I figured I was here and I had my t-shirt and this is half the battle. A kind woman assisted me in getting my chip which after a great deal of back and forth and then the MC announcing and calling for chips and more back and forth I was chipped and marked. I thanked the kind woman who assisted me and we talked for a bit. She was originally from London and had 3 children who were all present to cheer her on. She was wanting to stay fit for her children and to be a good role model and she asked me if I was ready, trained and prepped…my response ‘well it’s just a 3 k run and a 12 km bike, that’s doable’ and she mentioned another 3 k run but I was unclear as the announcer came up to state the race was about to start.
The weather was cooler than I expected and I was grateful for opting out of the swim. Lake Huron is a force on a good day and today it was choppy, lots of white tops, the wind was my friend. (Again, this will be important later.) The run started good I held back and did not want to make the error of other races and blow my energy in the first km! It was a quick and beautiful run along the lake the water, trees, birds, butterflies and locals all out to cheer you on.
I finished my run strong and started the biking and there is a quick uphill and you are off on a long cool out and back. It was amazing the ride was nice going to the ‘1/2 way mark’ and at this point I thought they made an error as it should have said ‘3/4 of the WAY’ but it was good. I saw a sign that said ‘Pedal to the Medal’ and figured these are just things I need to let go funny errors in spelling and comments are par for the course as you race away.
As I turned back the wind picked up but as I stated the WIND IS YOUR FRIEND perhaps the kind that you don’t always want to hang out with but I was embracing the unexpected and just seeing what came with, no judgement. I saw the trail run as I headed back and thought ‘wow there are a lot of people on that run’ and then I started to ponder the comment of the woman who assisted me with the chip and the 1/2 way mark and as I headed back the last couple of km of the bike ride expecting my medal and my banana I realized as I came off my bike that there was another 3 km run.
So SURPRISE but everyone was cheering and telling me to hurry and I, like a teenager suffering from severe peer pressure, looked to Steve and said ‘I think there is another 3 km run’ he smiled and said ‘why yes there is’ and Charlotte had her sign and I was dumping my bike and now I was running passing the chip marker on the final 3 km run.
So I think there are times that it is good to read the directions of putting things together and knowing what to expect is good; however, in this case I think this was good. All races are like lessons. Some are amazing and you surprise yourself and others surprise you with another 3 km run! I embraced that as the women that ran past me with their age numbered legs at 53, 57 and 60 were inspiring and defeating but I was amazed at their stamina. I felt a bit better with the early 30 somethings going by but I embraced my marked 43 with pride.
Overall, I highly recommend this race for anyone at any level. The energy and the challenge are amazing. Small towns are a gift of community that I miss coming from London and afterwards when I ordered breakfast the familiar ‘Are you’se guys ready to order?’ reminded me of my Grandmothers home
Tara and Susan before the race start. Tara is wearing a red ball cap. Susan is wearing sunglasses and a bright blue t-shirt.
by Susan F
For the last three years, I have done the sprint duathlon. In 2015, I had not done any training and found the transition from the bike to the second run to be particularly troublesome. Last year I did some training in anticipation of that transition. However when I started the second run, my feet felt really flat and I had difficulty running. I attributed this to my somewhat overused running shoes and opted to finish the race in my bare feet.
In hindsight, the problem was not my sneakers. In April, I was diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease. My symptoms include an inability to make my right foot do what I want it to do. I now think this is why I had difficulty last year.
I used to like running. Now I find it frustrating because it just doesn’t feel normal. I almost bailed on the race this year, but my cousin Tara convinced me to participate. I decided that I would enjoy the morning, hanging out with my friends and fellow competitors. I walked most of the second leg, enjoying the sunshine, the views of Lake Huron and the amazing support from everyone involved. Fellow competitors, volunteers and strangers on the street smiled, waved, honked horns, and yelled words of encouragement as I passed by. I had fun.
I don’t know if I’ll do the race next year. I’ll decide how I feel closer to registration but I might volunteer if racing seems like too much.
Susan (left) and Tara (right) post race, smiling, with their medals.
Susan Fullerton, a lawyer working for the government, lives in Toronto. She is an avid traveller who has had varying levels of fitness throughout her life. These days, she’s focused on being a reformed hoarder, trying to make better choices about how she spends her time and money.
This weekend I raced in a short distance duathlon, I took Cheddar and Nat’s dog Kirby on a 5 km dog hike along with Sarah, Susan, and Gavin after the duathlon (good to keep moving, right?) and I went on 50 km social bike ride with Sarah and David the next day that ended in coffee and cruffins.
In the 217 in 2017 Facebook group I participate in each counted as a workout. But they’re very different workouts and one way you can see the difference is by looking at heart rate data.
Here’s the bike course of the duathlon:
The runs looked pretty much the same except for the short bits where I took walk breaks. Yikes. Hard work.
Here it is on my Garmin. The Garmin is a more accurate heart rate measure. It uses a chest strap rather than a wrist band.
The course starts with a hill and you can see that looking at the heart rate information.
Average heart rate: 153, Max heart rate: 166
Here’s the dog hike, by comparison.
And here’s the 50 km bike ride.
Here’s what that looked like on my Garmin.
Average heart rate: 117, Max heart rate: 150
I’ve written before about training using heart rate information. See here on why take it easy. See here on why go hard.
Do you pay attention to your heart rate when working out? Why? Why not?
It’s high summer here in the Northern hemisphere, and all that lovely weather is provoking all kinds of interesting activity. Blogger Tracyrwdeboer is back on the bike, Susan is car camping, Tracy I is celebrating her discovery of active dresses for everyday summer walking to work and conferencing, and Sam is doing her best to ride long and not get hit by hail or lightning.
So what am I up to? Cycling– cycling as much as I can, as often as I can, with whomever will ride with me. I’m doing this for several reasons. In no particular order, they are:
1)I’m doing the PWA Friends for Life Bike Rally one-day ride with Sam, Sarah, Judy, and others (my apologies for not remembering the whole list). Sam is doing all six days from Toronto to Montreal, and a bunch of the bloggers have done the six-day ride as well. I’m not ready for that (and frankly, not a camping fan), so the one-day 110k ride from Toronto to Port Hope is right for me as a goal.
2) I haven’t been riding much at all for the past 2 years. But, for the past couple of months, I have been slowly returning to more active cycling. It’s been hard and continues to be hard. I’m older, heavier, and remember too well times when I was faster and the rides went easier. But here I am, looking to find my new normal. I’m not there yet, but am making my way. I want to find comfort and pleasure again on the saddle, and so logging some time and miles is the way to find it.
3) Riding more also means riding more with friends, reaffirming my identity as an active person, and sharing fun experiences with them on two wheels. I’ve been riding regularly with my friend Pata. On July 4th, I did a gorgeous ride around Cape Ann north of Boston with my friend Janet. We glided by beaches and rocks and ocean and parks and clam shacks. And she will testify that I didn’t actually complain until we were, (unbeknownst to me), .5 miles from the end of the ride. Not too bad… 🙂
I have plans to do a group ride with a bunch of friends next weekend, and will be riding hopefully with Jen, who is training for the Pan-Mass Challenge charity ride. I know, this seems like summer cycling business as usual. But for me it represents a return to the life I used to have, a life that got lost in the shuffle of life events, physical changes, and loss of focus.
I’m back. And I rode 100+ miles this week! here’s the breakdown:
Monday: 16 miles with Pata
Tuesday: 27 miles on Cape Ann with Janet
Tuesday: 10 miles of Brompton commuting to see July 4th fireworks
Thursday: 30 miles with Pata
Saturday: threshold ride, 13 miles total
Sunday: ride to and from church, 16 miles
total for week: 112 miles
I don’t remember the last time I rode that much in a week. But I will be riding that much next week. And the week after. And so on.