fitness

Why Do I Meditate (almost daily)?

I can’t even remember exactly when I started meditating. It was somewhere in the early 2000s. I had a ghost-writing client who had a meditation practice and was writing about it. Or rather, I was writing about it for him. As him. That is, after all, what ghost writing is. So, in the spirit of understanding the mind from which I was supposed to be writing (that is, the mind of my client), I thought, I ought to meditate a little, to see what it’s all about.  

At first, I meditated fitfully. There was no regularity in my practice and when I sat, my mind could not even grasp itself. The whole idea of watching my thoughts like so many passing clouds, as some meditation teachers proposed, was an image that did not speak to me. My thoughts were more like a rickety wagon, piled precariously high with junk, under constant threat of toppling, if the wheels didn’t just fall off first.

I found a low-key meditation center in New York City and went from time to time. Mostly with a friend. Every once in a while, on my own. Sometime before 2009, I recall doing a walking meditation on a misty summer day, during which I walked around the house my then-partner and I had in Vermont. Passing barefoot over grass and our pebbly driveway and flagstones. I might have done that meditation more than once. Not often enough that it rose to the level of ritual. I know it was before 2009, because we sold the house that year.

Still fitful, my practice was deepened by three silent meditation retreats and a vision quest. Again, I can’t quite remember when the first retreat was, possibly 2012. I do recall that after a retreat in October 2014, I joined the Insight Timer meditation app, which I’ve been on ever since. I remember the timing, because on my way home from the airport after the retreat, I had the conversation with my father in which he told me that he had decided to stop radiation treatment for his skin cancer. He died 6 months later.

At this point, my meditation was far from daily. Now and then, I would set myself a goal of 10 days in a row, which felt heroic. Then, at the end of 2018, following a teaching session about meditation with a group of friends (an experience we’d bid on at a gala), I set myself the goal of 30 days in a row. Never done before.  

Now that I’m writing this down here, I see that was a step change moment in my practice. Since then, my meditation practice has been a succession of long periods of daily sitting, followed by no more than a month of not-quite-daily, then a return to daily practice.  

Two shifts happened. I became conscious of whether I had meditated on any particular day. And, after much self-testing, I realized that, for me, longer than 10 minutes was not necessarily better and something was better than nothing. With these two shifts, meditation has become part of my daily routine, akin to drinking water, sleeping and brushing my teeth. A third and more recent shift, since I started living alone, is that I allow myself to meditate in bed first thing in the morning (or, if I’m not sleeping, sometime in the wee hours to help myself get back to sleep), instead of always getting up to sit on my cushion.  

Here’s what has happened when I meditate almost daily. I’ve become more aware of my thoughts as they are arising. I can even find that sacred pause between thinking a thought and acting on that thought. Less often than I’d like. Which is okay, because the sacred pause is a lifelong practice.  

Here’s what has not happened. The rickety wagon of junk is still there. Except now, I notice more of the distinct thoughts on the pile. Which means it is less precarious. Just noticing increases my capacity to be with uncomfortable thoughts without descending into self-laceration or lashing out at others.

A weathered red cart with a glass front, filled with cardboard boxes and a green bag, sitting on a street with two rusty wheels.

Recently, I’ve been engaging even more specifically in the practice of noticing. My only goal in my meditation is to notice my thoughts. I’m listening to the same 20-minute meditation every morning, which begins with a body scan. This makes it easy to notice when my mind has wandered away and when it comes back.

On Monday, for example, I breathed in and said to myself, I am aware and breathed out and said to myself, I am aware of my feet. As instructed. My attention stayed enough in the meditation to get to breathing in and out and being aware of my thighs. But then I totally missed my pelvis, belly and heart, my attention returning to the meditation as I was being guided to breathe in and say to myself, I am aware and breathe out and say to myself, I am aware of my nose. What was I thinking when I should have been breathing in and out awareness of my midsection?

Here’s a random sampling of thoughts: My legs are tired. I don’t want to take the day off, because I only have a few days left before I leave the mountains and won’t be able to cross-country ski. I need to get caught up on email. My heart feels squeezed. I should have looked at email on the weekend. But it was so nice to read Greenwood instead. Do I love trees enough? Am I being genuine when I hug my tree at home? Did I miss the pelvis in this meditation? I still feel put off by how sharp M was with me on the phone. When will I mend the holes in my cross-country ski long johns? I don’t want to spend money on new ones. Why does my thumbnail grow back faster in that corner? Don’t forget to cut your nails today. I’m running short on tahini, so I’ll have hazelnut butter by itself on my toast and save the tahini for my roasted vegetables. Are we already at the nose? I miss my matcha. I’m lonely.  How great is that bran muffin without raisins at Blondies? Why do people like raisins in muffins and other things, like cinnamon bread? Tragic. I miss my mother, even though she would never leave the raisins out. Should I wear the green sweater today? Why have I never heard that line before in this meditation?

And on and on it goes. Incredibly rarely I’ll have a moment, a glimpse, a nano-awakening to something important or simply touch a state of open awareness and connection with all that is. Mostly it’s about bran muffins and fingernails and emails.

So why do I meditate? Because of this: The practice of noticing that meditation enables creates space between thought and action. Even if that space is only infinitesimally larger than it was before, that space, that sacred pause, is the moment where I expand my self-compassion and my compassion for others.

That’s why I meditate.

Oh, and, also for the gold stars from Insight Timer. Tomorrow, all going well, I will hit a nice milestone of days in a row, which I won’t mention, because I don’t want to jinx my little dopamine hit.

habits · meditation · mindfulness · WOTY

Lying to Myself About Meditation

Monday morning. May 8th 2023. I wake up after an unusually restful night of sleep. I know I got up to the bathroom once. Other than that, I have no recollection of sleepless restlessness, which is not the norm for me these last many months. The first thing I notice is the fading rose of the light on the buildings out my window, soft and clear. I am surprised the day is here. I check my iPad for the time. It’s on the bedside table. Reading a novel (on the kindle app on my iPad) in bed as I fall asleep is one of my life’s pleasures.

And, in that moment, reaching for the time, I realize this: I did not meditate yesterday. Horror! How could I have forgotten?

I comb back through the day. It was not my typical Sunday. To start with, I didn’t get into bed until 4:00 am. I was taking part in a big group photo shoot organized by some friends, which didn’t start until past midnight. That same morning, I stayed longer in bed than usual … waiting until the moment before I needed to leave for my 5 Rhythms group at noon. I left my iPad out in a particular location to remind myself to meditate when I got back. But not with a note, as I often do, if I don’t meditate first thing in the morning.

That was May 7th. My cousin’s birthday. He was born 4 days before me. It would have been 1617 days of meditation in a row. 617 days since the last day of the first in-person visit with my mother after pandemic.

My streak!!?? I couldn’t lose my meditation streak, too! Enough with the loss already (I won’t get into the details—I’ve written about them the last couple of months.)

I recalled that while I was lying in bed Sunday morning, I had thought to myself, maybe 5 Rhythms will be my meditation today. After all, Gabrielle Roth, who developed the technique, called it a moving mediation. Still, if I’m honest, I wasn’t thinking about that anymore when I got to the studio. I was just inside my body, inside the dance. So, did it count if I hadn’t thought to myself, in the moment, this is my meditation?

I’ve been meditating daily for more than 4 years now, and I have adjusted my expectations and the form my meditation can take several times. For example, when I started, I required of myself a minimum of 20 minutes. After a month, I relaxed into any amount of time counting, so long as I sat down intentionally. My meditations now are most commonly 10 minutes long. Another requirement was that I be seated—a cushion or a chair (airplane seats count) or a patch of grass. Just seated, you get the picture. Then, about six months ago, when life got especially challenging, I began to relax the seated requirement and relaxed into lying down meditation. Sometimes (often on days when I’ve woken up super early or am having trouble motivating myself to get out of bed), I start my day with a meditation in bed. 

So, I am not averse to adjusting my meditation habits over time. And, I’ve never made the adjustment unconsciously. And, I’ve never included a moving meditation in my streak, at least not before May 7th. And, I do think it’s appropriate to count 5 Rhythms as a meditation, though I’d probably feel differently if it was the only form of daily meditation I practiced every day, which is how I feel about lying down meditation, too. Yes, at times the system of rules and regulations and definitions of what counts and what doesn’t inside my head verge on the Kafkaesque. For example, I don’t count riding around town on a bike as my workout, but I’ve also realized that it is a factor that needs to inform the workout I choose to do on a day when I’ll be riding around town a lot.

Which brings me back to my immediate problem on May 8th—what should I do about the meditation streak?

First, I decided to meditate, with the intention to notice what was coming up around the issue. Then, I thought, why bother? You’re just fooling yourself. You’re back to zero. You won’t get back into the 1600s on a new streak until you’re into your sixties. Suck it up. I sat down to meditate anyway. I considered whether there was a freedom in not being on the streak anymore. I’ve got a number of new, unasked for and unwanted, freedoms in my life. I don’t want more of these types of freedoms.

These thoughts crowded my mind: I have deep expertise in the field of being hard on myself, maybe this was not the moment? But if I follow that logic, was I at risk of being too gentle? What long time discipline would I cheat on next? If I decided to count 5 Rhythms, was I lying to myself? What would I lie to myself about next? A rabbit hole of dire possibilities yawned open.

Then, as if switch flipped, my mind quieted and I heard, count it. Add the session into your log. The streak motivates you If after a few days, you feel like a lying, cheating fraud, you can always take it out.

Well, it’s been more than a week now. When I look at my streak count, which is, as I type this (on Friday May 19, is 1628, I feel no remorse. I’ve come clean here about my streak. That’s enough. No public hanging required. I will continue on with my streak.

That last sentence was supposed to be the end of this post. My intention was to let the writing sit over the weekend and come back to polish the next week.

Except.

Saturday morning. May 20th 2023. I finish my run and decide to meditate outdoors. It’s only then that I realize, holy fucking shit, I did not meditate on Friday. The very day I was writing my first draft of this post, I forgot to meditate. Again. And this time, there was no 5 Rhythms waiting in the wings to save me. I was stunned. Was this the universe punishing me because I was lying to myself about my meditation streak with my 5 Rhythms fiddle? I sat down to meditate on my new streak-less reality. As I listened to the wind in the trees and breathed the breeze, waves of grief, followed by waves of jubilation rocked through my body. Each wave swelling into the space of the receding wave, as grief rolled into jubilation rolled into grief. For everything that’s been happening. When I finished my meditation, I was shaken. And I accepted. No, more than that, I welcomed what was. That was my word of the year, here was a reminder of the practice. I was not being punished or tested or whatever. I was living and doing the best I can. Later that day I bought a bottle of champagne to share with the friends I was having dinner with. To celebrate the ongoing deconstruction of my life.

This was the quote on my Insight Timer app on the day I realized that I’d forgotten to meditate. It felt like a message addressed to me rather directly. And the other image is my welcome to what now is.

I’m on day 4 of my new streak today. Or so Insight Timer tells me. And I don’t intend to streak for the time being. I will take the days as they come.