From the New York Times: “The report on nearly three million people found that those whose B.M.I. ranked them as overweight had less risk of dying than people of normal weight. And while obese people had a greater mortality risk over all, those at the lowest obesity level (B.M.I. of 30 to 34.9) were not more likely to die than normal-weight people. The report, although not the first to suggest this relationship between B.M.I. and mortality, is by far the largest and most carefully done, analyzing nearly 100 studies, experts said.”
This is in keeping with a declaration made by The New York Times in 1912 when they declared Elsie Scheel, “the perfect woman” at 171 lbs.
Read more here: The ‘Perfect Woman’ In 1912, Elsie Scheel, Was 171 Pounds And Loved Beefsteaks
Blogger Kate Harding described Scheel in these terms: “Miss Elsie Scheel’s BMI would have been 26.8, placing her squarely in today’s dreaded “overweight” category. At Banana Republic, to pick a random contemporary store, she would wear a size 8 top, a 12/14 bottom, and probably a 12 dress with the bust taken in.” (Kate Harding is the author of the BMI Project.)
I’ve written a bit about the so-called obesity paradox, Obesity, health, and fitness: some odd connections.
That’s okay. I’m not worried. I’ve been in the overweight category all of my adult life, even at my thinnest. Given my 122 lb base of muscle and bone, I’ll always be overweight. Which is, I’ve argued here, part of the problem with weight and BMI as measures of anything meaningful.
I often wonder about the effect of news like this on the naturally lean. One of thing that interests me is that it seems it just doesn’t matter how big the health benefits of being overweight are, no one would suggest that underweight people try to gain weight. It’s just too tough. Why doesn’t this work the other way?
3 thoughts on “Lower death risk for the overweight, go us!”
Interesting. I actually have known a few naturally lean people who have tried to gain weight and have been encouraged to do so. But you’re right, it’s pretty rare. From what I’ve heard, it’s also really difficult to do.
I struggle with one of the children, as you know. And he can eat a lot and not gain weight. In the book Rethinking Thin, the NY Times health reporter Gina Kolata looks at research done into deliberate weight gain and it’s very very hard and challenging. (That’s a great book on the science of weight gain and loss. It’s full title is Rethinking Thin: The New Science of Weight Loss—And the Myths and Realities of Dieting. She also looks at the health benefits of being overweight.)
Comments are closed.